Ask an expert. Trust the answer.

Your academic and career questions answered by verified experts

Why different result with PCA and SVD in Matlab?

Date: 2022-11-30 12:20:34

I have implemented my PCA function in Matlab in the following way: 

 

function e = myPCA(X) [D, N] = size(X); m = mean(X, 2); X = X - repmat(m, 1, N); [e, ~, ~] = svd(X,'econ'); end

When I use now the built in Matlab function [e, ~, ~] = pca(X'); I'm getting the same absolute values as with my function but for some columns of U the sign is flipped.

Which ones is the right way to go and why is there this difference in sign? 

Answer: 

It is true that the matrix you denote by e has columns which are the basis in which the covariance matrix is diagonal, as should be in PCA. However, an orthogonal basis stays an orthogonal basis if you flip any basis vector. For example, in 2D if the basis e you find via Matlab's pca is the axes x and y, then -x and -y is also a basis. Or stated slightly different, since for pca you find the eigenvectors of the covariance matrix, and since if v is an eigenvector then -v is also an eigenvector (with the same eigenvalue), we see that the principal components are defined up to a sign. Since svd and pca are implemented differently, you don't have a guaranty to get the same signs. 

 


Why Matlabhelpers ?

Our Matlab assignment helpers for online MATLAB assignment help service take utmost care of your assignments by keeping the codes simple yet of high-quality. We offer the most reliable MATLAB solutions to students pursuing their Computer Science course from the Monash University, the University of Sydney, the University of New South Wales, the University of Melbourne; to name a few. Approach us today for best Matlab solutions online!

whatsApp order on matlabhelpers.com

telegram order on matlabsolutions.com